The Plot Twist Within

Exercise #392 Characters That Defy Genre Expectations

Strategy:

In the realm of storytelling, expectations are made to be broken. By creating characters whose internal goals clash with the typical plot trajectory, we open up a treasure trove of narrative possibilities. This approach invites readers to question their assumptions about character roles and story arcs, leading to fresh, engaging narratives. When a hero suddenly prioritizes their personal life over saving the world, or a villain discovers a passion for knitting, we're not just subverting expectations—we're exploring the rich, complex nature of human motivation and the unpredictable path of self-discovery.

Learning Objectives:

1. Develop characters that challenge traditional genre roles and expectations

2. Explore the tension between external plot demands and internal character motivations

3. Practice creating unexpected narrative arcs that arise from character choices

4. Analyze how subverting expectations can lead to deeper character development and more engaging stories

Instructions:

1. Genre Setup: Choose a familiar genre (e.g., fantasy quest, spy thriller, romantic comedy) and briefly outline the typical plot expectations for a protagonist in this genre.

2. Character Creation: Develop a protagonist who initially seems to fit the chosen genre's archetype. Give them a basic background and the apparent skills/traits needed for their expected role.

3. The Twist: Introduce an internal goal or desire for your protagonist that conflicts with their expected role in the plot. This should be something personal and seemingly unrelated to the main story.

4. Initial Conflict: Write a scene where your protagonist first realizes their personal goal is at odds with their expected role. Focus on their internal struggle and initial attempts to balance both.

5. Escalation: Continue the scene, showing how the character's focus shifts more towards their personal goal, actively resisting or subverting the main plot. Explore the consequences of this shift.

6. New Direction: Briefly outline how this character's choice could lead the story in an unexpected direction, creating a new kind of conflict or growth opportunity that defies genre conventions.

Tags: subverting expectations, character development, genre-bending, internal conflict, narrative structure, creative writing, plot twists

Example:

1. Genre Setup: Classic space opera. The expectation is that the brave starship captain will lead their crew on a perilous mission to save the galaxy from an ancient, awakening evil.

2. Character Creation: Captain Fuuvu Starlight, decorated veteran of the Galactic Fleet, known for her tactical brilliance and unwavering dedication to duty. She's been chosen to lead a critical mission to shut down a galaxy-threatening superweapon.

3. The Twist: Fuuvu has recently discovered a passion for terrestrial gardening and has been growing increasingly disillusioned with the constant sacrifices demanded by her career. She yearns to settle down on a peaceful planet and cultivate rare, exotic plants.

4. Initial Conflict:

   The bridge of the starship hummed with tense energy as the crew prepared for their galaxy-saving mission. But Captain Fuuvu Starlight's mind was elsewhere, lingering on the image of the tiny greenhouse she'd set up in her quarters.

   "Captain, we're approaching the coordinates," her first officer reported crisply.

   Fuuvu blinked, forcing herself to focus on the swirling star map before her. "Right, of course. Prepare for—" She paused, a thought striking her. "Wait. Is that uninhabited planet we passed still within shuttle range?"

   The first officer frowned. "Yes, but... that's not our mission, Captain."

   Fuuvu's fingers twitched, imagining the feel of rich soil instead of cold starship controls. "I know, I just... I wonder what kind of unique flora might be growing there, untouched by civilization."

   "Captain?" The concern in her officer's voice was clear. "The fate of the galaxy—"

   "Yes, yes, of course," Fuuvu said quickly, pushing down the longing in her chest.

   "Continue on course."

5. Escalation:

   As days passed, Fuuvu found herself spending more time in her quarters, tending to her plants, than on the bridge. She began making increasingly frequent "detours" to survey potentially habitable planets, much to her crew's confusion and growing frustration.

   During a crucial strategy meeting, Fuuvu's attention wandered to the datapad hidden in her lap, scrolling through articles on exotic plant cultivation.

   "Captain!" her security chief's sharp voice cut through her reverie. "Did you hear the plan? We need your approval to proceed."

   Fuuvu looked up, suddenly aware of the expectant faces around her. The weight of the mission, of billions of lives, pressed down on her. But all she could think about was the peace she felt among her plants, the life-giving act of nurturing something beautiful.

   "I... I can't do this anymore," she said softly, then with growing conviction. "Plot a course for the nearest habitable planet. I'm retiring. And I'm taking you guys down with me."

   The stunned silence that followed was interrupted only by the occasional beep or bloop of a console button.

6. New Direction: Fuuvu's decision to abandon the mission could lead to a story that explores themes of burnout, the cost of constant heroism, and finding purpose in unexpected places. The crew might have to step up in her absence, leading to character growth for secondary characters. Alternatively, Fuuvu's choice to settle on a new planet could uncover a more sustainable solution to the galactic threat, one that involves nurturing life rather than engaging in battle. The story could evolve into an exploration of alternative forms of heroism and the power of stepping back to gain a new perspective on large-scale problems.

This is the final exercise posted here. Jump over to the new newsletter to keep your writing streak alive with 7 new writing exercises: Words, Not Ideas.